How to play against a friend in MLB The Show?
Use Diamond Dynasty! That's my go-to. Hop into the Diamond Dynasty menu, find 'Play vs Friends,' and challenge them directly. Always works for me.
Play Games.Earn points.Get gift cards!

Playback Rewards
(13.7k)
500k players and counting...
More Answers
Hot take: Exhibition mode in Diamond Dynasty. Less hassle than other methods!
First, add your friend via their PSN or Xbox Live username, then go to the Diamond Dynasty menu, select 'Play vs Friends,' and invite them to a match!
Easiest way? Just head to the 'Exhibition' mode, select 'Local Multiplayer', and set up your controllers to play on the same console. Simple and fun!
馃憖 If you like MLB The Show Companion App...
The brands referenced on this page are not sponsors of the rewards or otherwise affiliated with this company. The logos and other identifying marks attached are trademarks of and owned by each represented company and/or its affiliates. Please visit each company's website for additional terms and conditions.
People also want to know
Add an Answer