How to Substitute Pitcher in MLB The Show 24
To substitute a pitcher, press the Options button (on PS) or the Menu button (on Xbox) to bring up the in-game menu. Select the 'Manager' tab, choose the 'Bullpen' option, and replace your current pitcher with one from your bullpen!
Play Games.Earn points.Get gift cards!

Playback Rewards
(13.7k)
500k players and counting...
More Answers
Just press the Options/Menu button, head over to the bullpen section, and choose your desired pitcher to replace the current one.
Pause the game, go to the Manager tab, select Bullpen, and then choose the pitcher you want to bring into the game. Simple as that!
During a game, hit the pause button, navigate to the bullpen icon, and then just pick the pitcher you want to sub in. Easy peasy!
馃憖 If you like MLB The Show Companion App...
The brands referenced on this page are not sponsors of the rewards or otherwise affiliated with this company. The logos and other identifying marks attached are trademarks of and owned by each represented company and/or its affiliates. Please visit each company's website for additional terms and conditions.
People also want to know
Add an Answer